Oh, you hate homemade cranberry sauce? No one gives a shit.
When Linus starts talking about the origins of Thanksgiving in A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving, it becomes clear that the writers were looking to score big again and make it the highlight of the special, very similar to his "Lights, please?" speech from A Charlie Brown Christmas. Of course, that entire bit was lifted directly from the New Testament, and there's nothing in the Bible about Thanksgiving, so they had to actually write something for this precocious little know-it-all to say.
Something something friendship with Native Americans and God bless us everyone. No one remembers it, not simply because it's ahistorical bullshit, but because it's boring. The Bible is also mostly made-up but at least sometimes its memorably poetic. Anyway, people who watch A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving remember popcorn, jellybeans, pretzels, toast, hopefully some guest etiquette, and then the way Woodstock happily eats another bird at the end.
None of what I just wrote has anything to do with what follows, but I was thinking about it, and now you've read it. What does follow is me rambling a little about food and I don't have a good ending, which you should know now, I guess, but you're here, so read it anyway.
If you're observing Thanksgiving, it's because you want to eat. This is why I do it. It's Food Day. I also like to eat that food with friends. Even when I couldn't cook (hip replacement surgery, November 20, 2023), some friends came over and we ordered Chinese food and I ate some dumplings in between recovery naps and watching Brandy on a parade float and it was fantastic.
This year I'm cooking, as are several friends and family members wrangled for the purpose of various potato recipes, macaroni and cheese, cornbread, pies, and I forget what else. The guest list keeps growing so I have to text everyone to tell them to double up their recipes. I borrow extra drinking glasses. I buy four new folding chairs. This weekend I'll make gravy and a huge amount of stuffing and freeze it all. This works very nicely, by the way. There's no reason to grind yourself into dust on the last Thursday of the month. Do it early. Sit down and have a drink.
Every carnivore likes turkey as long as it's properly prepared, and I prepare it properly. I've already roasted a full 14lb turkey, carved it up, and put it in the freezer as back-up meat. On the day, I'll roast a second one because we'll run out otherwise. I could pre-roast the second one if I wanted peak efficiency, but it's nice to have one on the table for people to look at.
There is a cranberry war, and people get very full of their feelings about it. I don't know why, but they are vocal. They get upset. It's a bit. At least I tell myself it's a bit.
I'm here to please. I have two cans of Ocean Spray cranberry sauce at the ready. It will be on the table, each can opened into a different serving vessel, so that it's never too far out of anyone's reach. People love it. I understand.
I'm making homemade, as well, and this is where the trouble begins. I will always choose homemade over canned. The canned kind is good enough; I like to spread it on turkey sandwiches. However, on its own it's too sweet for me. My own homemade – I wouldn't call it astringent but it's quite tart because I use this Alison Roman recipe and employ about half the sugar she recommends – is my preference.
The internet is a silly place, and internet people are proud to plant a flag in the hill of canned cranberry sauce, a hill upon which they are willing to perish. This is fine. They can do that.
But it also enters my home. Several friends are soldiers in the cranberry war. They enlisted themselves and they bring their grenades to Thanksgiving lunch. There's an amusing annual moment, as we all gather at the table, when I see and hear these friends who love me turn up their noses at the homemade sauce and announce that it's bad, refusing to taste it at all because CANNED ONLY, FUCK YOU DAVE WHITE.
But their little cranberry opinions are meaningless to me. I don't have to respond in protest or give an explanation because there's too much deliciousness around them and they're about to find out. They have look to each other for confirmation that they're correct because I'm very busy sitting there and eating my food which is what they should be doing.
When they remember that fact, they forget that they're being fake-angry for low-level comedy reasons and we all get the cranberries we desire and the turkey breast is going to be juicy. Almost too juicy. Juicy-gotcha-krazy juicy. Juicy.
[100% REAL VINTAGE PHOTO STOLEN FROM THE GREAT CHARLES PHOENIX, ONE OF AMERICA'S MOST SIGNIFICANT AND HISTORICALLY FUN GAYS. GO TO CHARLESPHOENIX.COM TO LEARN MORE]